Musicians and singers trying to break into movies is nothing new. Early musical crooners and rock ‘n’ roll icons like Bing Crosby, Elvis Presley and Frank Sinatra were among the first major recording artists to successfully turn their singing fame into lucrative movie careers. Bing Crosby even won an Academy Award. Others followed suit over the decades. The allure of going from selling out arenas and stadiums to filling cinema screens is strong. However, it doesn’t always go to plan. Here are seven pop stars that made the jump from the stage to the silver screen in a bid for movie superstardom and didn’t quite make it.
Madonna
The first artist on our list may be one of the most successful. Madonna released a string of chart-topping albums in the 1980s, before transitioning to the silver screen with roles in Desperately Seeking Susan (1985) and Who’s That Girl (1987). The pop star continued to act through the 1990s while still maintaining her thriving musical career. For example, she appeared in the comic strip-inspired Dick Tracy and the baseball comedy In A League of Their Own. However, it was her tour de force performance as Eva Peron in the musical Evita (1996) that brought her critical and popular acclaim. She even won a Golden Globe Award for her role as Argentina’s former First Lady.
Of course, what goes up must invariably come down, and for Madonna, that was 2002’s box office bomb, Swept Away, directed by her one-time husband, Guy Richie. A remake of a 1970s Italian film, Madonna’s performance was lambasted by critics and audiences alike. The words “wooden” and “lifeless” were bandied about. Madonna subsequently won a Golden Raspberry Award for Worst Actress. It wasn’t quite the end of her acting career, of course. She had a small role in Die Another Day and transitioned mainly to doing cameos and voice work. In 2008, the pop superstar also made her directorial debut with Filth and Wisdom, a low-budget British comedy-drama. So, while her acting career hasn’t achieved the insane levels of her music career, Madonna has still enjoyed a decades-old relationship in Tinseltown.
Britney Spears
Britney Spears is a bona fide global superstar who burst onto the scene in the late 90s and almost single-handedly revived the teen pop musical genre, starting with her debut single, Baby One More Time, released in 1998. Indeed, her first two albums shattered record sales and solidified her pop icon status. With such success, it was inevitable that Hollywood would come calling, and call they did. Britney Spears made her big screen debut in 2002’s Crossroads, directed by Shonda Rhimes (she of Grey’s Anatomy and other high-profile TV shows).
Needless to say, the critics savaged the film… and some tore into Britney’s performance as well; her awkward line delivery and blank expression were particularly singled out. Not every reviewer hated Britney’s performance, though; a few found her genuinely endearing and sincere, noting she possessed a real screen presence. However, that did not stop her from being nominated for a Golden Raspberry Award, tying in first place with Madonna for the aforementioned Swept Away. Again, the pop superstar did receive a few positive nominations, the literal definition of mixed results.
After Crossroads, Britney stopped pursuing a traditional acting career, transitioning to doing comedic cameos in films like Goldmember (2002) and Corporate Animals (2019). She also appeared in How I Met Your Mother and Jane the Virgin. Of course, she continued to pursue her successful music career, releasing albums throughout the 1990s and 2000s, including what many consider to be her magnum opus, Blackout, in 2007. So while she might not have become a movie icon, her place among the best-selling artists of all time is most definitely assured.
Mariah Carey
Vocal powerhouse Mariah Carey burst onto the scene in the early 90s with her self-titled debut album, which scored not one but four consecutive number one singles. More blockbusting albums followed throughout the 1990s, including Music Box (1993) and Day Dream (1995), both producing even more chart-topping singles. In between, the “Songbird Supreme” (as Guinness World Records called her) released a Christmas album, and its lead single, All I Want for Christmas Is You, has become Mariah Carey’s most lasting legacy (probably). An unparalleled seasonal phenomenon, the song routinely returns to the top of global charts every holiday season.
Mariah Carey continued making music through the late 1990s and 2000s. Inevitably, she made the jump to the silver screen with 2001’s romantic musical Glitter, a notorious box office stinker that was torn to shreds by critics and audiences alike. Some reviewers unflatteringly compared Carey’s acting to a giddy chipmunk, not the sort of notice you want to have when trying to build a movie career. It will probably come as no shock to learn the singing sensation won the Razzie Award for Worst Actress that year.
However, that was not the end of Mariah Carey’s acting career. She bounced back with 2009’s Precious, stripping down her usually glamorous persona to play Mrs Weiss, a dowdy, empathetic social worker in that film. Her subtle, understated performance earned her ensemble nominations at the SAG (Screen Actors Guild) Awards. After that, Carey appeared in films like The Butler (2013) and even voiced a character in The Lego Batman Movie (2017). In short, Mariah Carey’s acting career may not have shot into the stratosphere like her music career, but it hasn’t crashed and burned like others either.
Prince
Has there ever been a more gifted musician than Prince? The man was an incomparable musical virtuoso and multi-instrumentalist, as well as one of the most prolific songwriters of his generation. A veritable genius, Prince played all 27 instruments on his 1978 debut album, and his legend only grew with the release of subsequent records in the 70s and 80s. However, his undisputed masterpiece has to be 1984’s Purple Rain. This masterwork spent a consecutive 24 weeks at number one and yielded iconic singles like When Doves Cry and Let’s Go Crazy, not to mention the titular track.
That same year, Prince made his acting debut in the semi-autobiographical rock musical drama of the same name. Purple Rain was a box office success for Prince, sweeping over $70 million at the box office. Prince also won an Academy Award for Best Original Song Score at the Oscars. That meant he was the first artist to simultaneously hold the number one album, single and film in the U.S. Surprisingly, critics didn’t hate his performance in the film either. All in all, 1984 was a good year for Prince.
That changed in 1986. Prince made his directorial debut and starred in Under the Cherry Moon, a comedy romance film about two con artist brothers who plan to swindle a wealthy heiress. It bombed at the box office and became cannon fodder for critics who couldn’t wait to tear it apart. Prince’s performance was lambasted as being too self-indulgent and theatrical. The artist made a different type of history as his film swept the Razzies that year, where Under the Cherry Moon won the Worst Actor, Worst Picture and Worst Director Awards. Ouch.
Prince tried, bless him, releasing Graffiti Bridge (the sequel to Purple Rain) in 1990. By then, it was too little too late. Audiences were tired of Prince the actor. But they never tired of Prince, the musician. When Prince was able to play his music on screen, such as in Purple Rain or his self-directed Sign o’ the Times concert documentary (itself based on the wonderful 1987 album of the same name), his physical commitment and presence elevated the medium in a way few other musicians have ever managed. And that’s the best compliment one can pay Prince.
Mick Jagger
If there’s such a thing as a quintessential rock frontman, Mick Jagger would be it. Globally renowned for his distinct vocals, electric countercultural energy, and signature, athletic stage antics, the supremely talented rocker started his career way back in the early 1960s, when he partnered with Keith Richards to form the legendary rock group, The Rolling Stones. The rest, as they say, is history. Hit after hit followed thanks to their songwriting partnership, (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction, Sympathy for the Devil and Gimme Shelter, among many other iconic classics.
Jagger also got his start in the film business early on in his music career. In the 1970s, he starred in not one but two films. The first was Ned Kelly, based on the exploits of the famous Australian outlaw. The second was Performance, where he plays a reclusive, decadent rock star, probably not a stretch for the singer-songwriter. Indeed, critics praised his performance at the time. Despite these early successful forays into the film industry, Jagger decided to forgo traditional leading man roles for something more eclectic.
For example, he starred as a smarmy corporate type in 1992’s Freejack, a sci-fi action film about a race car driver who’s thrust into the future, and that few people probably remember today. He later played a cross-dressing cabaret host in Bent (1997) and a manipulative art dealer in The Burnt Orange Heresy (2019). Jagger is also the subject of a couple of intriguing “what if” scenarios. He was slated to play Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen in Alejandro Jodorowsky’s unmade Dune adaptation. He also filmed scenes for Werner Herzog’s Fitzcarraldo (1982), before scheduling conflicts forced him to depart the project. He was replaced by notorious hellraiser Klaus Kinski.
Not that Jagger probably cares that much. His band has remained at the forefront of rock music for decades now, and he and Keith Richards have forged a musical legacy that will live on through the ages. And his foray into the movie business has been nothing if not unique.
Beyoncé
One of the best-selling artists of all time (not to mention the record holder for most Grammy Award wins in history), Beyoncé’s story begins in the late 90s when she fronted the R&B group Destiny’s Child alongside Kelly Rowland (who also went on to have a truncated film career) and Michelle Williams (who no-one seems to remember). The band dominated the global charts in the late 1990s and early 2000s with such anthems as Say My Name and Survivor. In 2003, she launched an even more lucrative solo career with the release of her solo album, Dangerously In Love. Beyoncé has dominated the music scene ever since, releasing chart-topping album after chart-topping album, and mastering different genres like house, disco and even country.
Naturally for a global superstar like Beyoncé, the movies inevitably came a-knocking, and she made her film debut as Foxy Cleopatra in Austin Powers in Goldmember (2002) and followed this up with a comedic turn in 2006’s The Pink Panther remake. Critical reception to her acting ability was mixed. Reviewers praised her screen presence but derided her dramatic acting chops. Not that it stopped Beyoncé. In 2006, she starred as Deena Jones in the musical drama, Dreamgirls, and was rewarded with a Golden Globe nomination for her troubles.
More movie work followed in films like Cadillac Records (2008) and Obsessed (2009). However, the apogee of her film career (so far) is her turn as Nala in Disney’s “live action” version of The Lion King (2019). Since then, Beyoncé has stepped behind the camera to direct the Emmy-nominated concert film, Homecoming (2019), and the Disney+ musical art film, Black is King (2020). So, while Beyoncé might not have catapulted to the top of Hollywood, we’re sure she’s not crying into her multiple Grammys either. Not only is Beyoncé already music royalty, she’s now finding her feet as an auteur in the visual arts medium as well.
Justin Timberlake
If Britney Spears was once the Princess of Pop, then surely Justin Timberlake was the Prince of Pop (with Michael Jackson as the King of Pop and Madonna as the Queen). Incidentally, Justin and Britney dated at one time. Justin Timberlake’s career began back in the late 1990s/early 2000s, when he became the breakout star of the boy band, NSYNC. The group’s diamond-certified album, No Strings Attached, shattered all records and set the standard for all boy bands that followed. In 2002, Justin launched his own successful solo career, with the album Justified producing hit singles like Cry Me A River. After releasing yet another successful solo album in the mid-2000s, Justin Timberlake decided he wanted to launch an equally lucrative movie career.
He made his debut in 2010’s The Social Network, about the creation of a little-known social media platform you might have heard of, Facebook. He received critical plaudits for his turn as Napster co-founder Sean Parker. Then, Timberlake actually became a leading man in films like Friends With Benefits, Bad Teacher and In Time. Later, he appeared in more dramatic fare in Inside Llewyn Davis (2013), the Apple+ TV show, Palmer (2021), and Reptile (2023), the latter with Benicio del Toro.
Like most pop stars’ movie careers, Justin Timberlake hasn’t quite been able to get to the top of Hollywood’s greasy pole, although it’s fair to say that he has found longer-lasting success than most of the artists on this list. The singer-songwriter has also found a second wind on TV, particularly Saturday Night Live, where he performs hilarious comedy sketches alongside the likes of Lonely Island. Plus, Justin serves as the main voice actor and executive music producer for DreamWorks’ multi-billion-dollar Trolls animated franchise, with multiple films already under his belt. So he’s probably not complaining too much.
Notable Mentions
Earlier, we mentioned Kelly Rowland and her chequered film career. We could also just as well have mentioned Britney Spears’ one-time Mickey Mouse Club collaborator, Christina Aguilera. Unlike Justin Timberlake, Christina’s main claim to fame (outside her hugely successful music career, of course) is 2010’s musical drama Burlesque, also starring the legendary Cher. Outside that, she’s done some voice work in films like Shark Tale (2004) and The Emoji Movie (2017).
Rihanna may be a global powerhouse in the realm of music, selling a bazillion albums, but she’s struggled to make headway in Hollywood. Her big film debut came in 2012’s box office flop, Battleship (not even Liam Neeson could save that movie). Her performance was panned by critics, and she won a Razzie Award for Worst Supporting Actress. Since then, she’s appeared in such diverse films as Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets (2017) and Ocean’s 8 (2018); neither set the box office on fire.
Michael Jackson may have been the King of Pop, with some of the best songs to grace the airwaves and the small screen. And though his music videos are some of the best made (Smooth Criminal is a particular favourite), it never transitioned to big-screen success. Still, 1978’s The Wiz (a contemporary reimagining of The Wizard of Oz) was a promising start, as the film earned him the best reviews of the entire cast. The next big landmark was 1988’s Moonwalker, a surreal anthology-type film with a thin plot that was stitched together with some awesome music videos, including the aforementioned Smooth Criminal. After that, Jackson’s acting career was relegated to cameo appearances in 2002’s Men in Black II (which was hilarious and a bit sad) and uncredited voice work in The Simpsons.
Speaking of Simpson (that’s what we call a smooth transition), the last honourable mention is Jessica Simpson. Emerging in the late 1990s/early 2000s alongside other pop princesses like Britney and Christina, Jessica found success first as a singer and eventually as a reality TV star and fashion/lifestyle mogul. In between, she transitioned into movies with 2005’s The Dukes of Hazzard. Needless to say, both the film and her performance were critically nuked. She made the odd appearance in subsequent films; however, any hopes of making it in movies were dashed. With a reported $200 million net worth thanks to her reality show empire, we don’t think she minds too much.