27 October. Cancel your plans. Book annual leave. Put your phone on Do Not Disturb. That’s the day Sarah J. Maas finally releases the next installment in the A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR) series.

Titled A Court of Splintered Harmony, the anticipation is… how do we put this delicately?

We’re feral.

And Sarah J Maas? Maas has revealed nothing. NOTHING, apart from the title! No cover. No blurb. No teaser chapter. No cryptic Instagram caption with a suspiciously placed bat emoji. She’s locked this thing down tighter than Fort Knox. Even the CIA is probably looking at her marketing strategy and thinking, “Bit excessive.”

So naturally the fandom has done what any perfectly rational group of readers would do: we’ve built conspiracy boards, connected invisible dots, and analysed bonus chapters like they contain the Da Vinci Code, fuelling those BookTok trends.

So what can we expect in this much-anticipated 6th book? Well, strap in. Let’s take a closer look into some of the biggest theories doing the rounds in the fandom…

Theory 1: Will Azriel Be The Protagonist of ACOTAR Book 6?

Poor Azriel. The man has spent 500 years pining after Mor. Five. Hundred. Years.

Mate, read the room.

Now we’ve got Elain. We’ve got Gwyn. We’ve got Lucien awkwardly standing in the corner, clutching an unwanted mating bond while Elain treats it like terms and conditions she never agreed to. The biggest debate in the Romantasy fandom is basically: Team Elriel / Team Gwynriel / Team Elucien. And what a catch Az is – he’s tall, strong, brooding, with tousled black hair and seven cobalt-blue Siphons to help him control his sex-appeal power. He dresses all in black Illyrian fighting leathers like a beautiful goth assassin with trust issues. And don’t get me started on his wingspan – my ovaries can only handle so much. 

Elain and Azriel have undeniable chemistry. He clearly has genuine affection for her; after all, he’s not loaning out Truth Teller to just any honey-haired Seer. Add to that all that sexual tension in the bonus chapter. Girl, gurrrrl…

Maas has also hinted that mating bonds aren’t necessarily infallible. Which only raises more questions: Is Elain’s bond with Lucien genuine and can mating bonds actually be wrong? Is it a red herring to deliberately throw us off track?

Then there’s Lucien himself. The poor bloke has done literally nothing wrong. He’s been patient, respectful and given Elain space, which, in romance novels, usually means you’re either destined to be together or you’re firmly planted in the friend zone in perpetuity. I’m inclined to believe the latter. 

Then Gwyn strolls into the picture. She’s funny. She’s fierce. She’s becoming a Valkyrie. In French she would be called ‘la renarde’ and she would hunt with only her cunning to protect her. Azriel smiles when he thinks about her. He SMILES! Dude never smiles. 

And if Book 6 does in fact belong to Azriel, then hopefully we’ll get an explanation as to what a Shadowsinger actually is.

Seriously, what are the shadows? Magic? Living creatures? Where did they come from? Why do they like him? The man is one of the most mysterious characters Maas has ever written, and five books later all we have to go on are his brooding vibes, childhood trauma and impressive wingspan (I had to bring it up again).

Theory 2: Could Elain Archeron Lead The Next ACOTAR Book?

This feels like the safest bet. Feyre had her story. Nesta had hers. Elain is the last Archeron sister waiting in the (bat)wings. Except, nobody really knows who Elain really is. She’s a Seer, she’s connected to the Cauldron and she quietly stabbed the King of Hybern in one of the most badass moments in the series… and then politely wandered back to gardening with full tradwife energy. The problem with dear, sweet Elain is that she is so boring – finding anything interesting about her requires such a level of forensic analysis that it strains the human ability to give a damn.

Theory 3: Is The Crescent City And ACOTAR Crossover Finished?

After House of Sky and Breath and House of Flame and Shadow, most readers are convinced the crossover isn’t finished.

Whether Bryce pops back into Prythian or whether it’s just the wider Sarah J. Maas multiverse connecting everything together, very few people believe Maas opened that multiverse door just to slam it shut again.

Theory 4: Is Eris Vanserra Actually A Hero?

Cassian keeps noticing things with Mor don’t add up and Eris repeatedly hints there’s more to the story with Mor. He also opposes Beron and has a suspicious amount of honour for someone who is introduced as an absolute tool. Many fans think he’s being set up as the future High Lord of Autumn. Which, given Beron is still alive, will we see some good-old-fashioned patricide?

Theory 5: Is There A Traitor Within The Night Court?

One theory that’s been making the rounds for a while now is the possibility that Mor is hiding a lot more from the inner circle than we realise. For someone who’s power is ‘Truth’, she sure does lie and obfuscate a lot. She is also conveniently absent at times, refused to explain where she’s been, and fans have assembled them into the usual cork-board-red-string masterpiece. 

This ties into the side-theory that Azriel has not in fact been pining for Mor,, that he has been suspicious of her and has been watching her this whole time. I would class this one under ‘pass me the red string’. She’s been spending a suspicious amount of time on the main continent doing reconnaissance for Rhys and ‘building relationships’ with other courts. Does this account for Az, and to a degree, even Cassian’s suspicions of her?

The Wild Card: Could The Next Book Be A Prequel?

Now put down the red string for a second because this one goes fully off the map. What if Maas doesn’t move the story forward at all? What if, stay with me here, she takes us back 15,000 years instead!

Amren was around before the courts of Prythian existed. So was Koschei, the Weaver, the Bone Carver, Fionn, the Daglan and all those suspiciously vague “Age of Legends” people. We also still don’t know exactly how Koschei ended up bound to that lake, who the mysterious Fae warrior responsible really was, or exactly what Amren was doing when she first arrived in this world. Could Maas give us the ancient history of Prythian from someone who actually witnessed it?

It sets up book 7 and 8 for Koschei to be the new bad guy. Now that Hybern is gone, Maas needs to up the ante with an even more villainous character. Who better than an actual death god?

Soooo, What Happens Next?!?

The debate is only just beginning as the theory train keeps on rolling! The best part of the A Court of Thorns and Roses community is how avid readers interpret the clues in different ways. We all wait with bated breath until Maas decides to throw us some table scraps of information. 

So, who’s getting the next book? Is it Azriel, Elain, Lucien, or someone completely unexpected?

By the time this book comes out, we’ll all have the most shapely Illyrian calves from jumping to so many conclusions.

Roll on 27 October!