Harlan Coben is nothing if not prolific. The American author seems to have a new thriller adaptation landing on a streaming platform every few months, all stamped with his trademark blend of domestic mystery, moral murk and at least one twist you never see coming (and one you definitely do).
From The Stranger to Fool Me Once, Coben has built a reputation for sleek, bingeable thrillers that hook you with simple questions and keep you guessing right up to the final, usually implausible, reveal. His latest, Lazarus, arrives on Prime Video with that same familiar setup. But this time, the mystery takes a decidedly supernatural turn.
A Familiar Formula, With a Paranormal Twist
Coben’s best work usually begins with a single, irresistible question.
What if your dead husband appeared alive on your nanny cam? (Fool Me Once).
What if a stranger told you your wife’s been lying to you for years? (The Stranger).
Lazarus starts in a similar vein, forensic psychiatrist Joel Lazarus (Sam Claflin) is haunted by the brutal murder of his twin sister years earlier. He helps the police solve cold cases through psychological profiling, but his own life is unravelling.
After the apparent suicide of his father (played by the reliably excellent Bill Nighy), Joel finds an ominous note: “This isn’t over.” Then, while sorting through his father’s office, he meets a distraught young woman who pours out her heart to him, only for Joel to later realise she died years ago.
From there, the line between logic and lunacy dissolves. Ghostly apparitions, buried secrets, and long-suppressed trauma collide as Joel becomes convinced that the key to solving his father’s death (and perhaps his sister’s) lies somewhere between the living and the dead.
A Lot of Ideas, Not Enough Focus
Even by Coben standards, Lazarus is dense. It juggles murder mysteries, family trauma, psychic visions, and police-procedural elements, often all in the same scene. The result is more exhausting than enthralling.
Claflin’s Lazarus isn’t an uninteresting protagonist, he’s just oddly passive. Scenes happen to him rather than because of him. He stumbles from one bizarre encounter to the next, bewildered by the supernatural happenings around him. His confusion might mirror our own a bit too closely.
Bill Nighy, meanwhile, lends a touch of class and melancholy as the late Dr Lazarus Sr., though his presence is fleeting. Other characters drift in and out, including detectives, ghosts and possible suspects, without ever anchoring the story emotionally. It’s a shame, because Coben’s thrillers usually thrive on relatable chaos: ordinary people thrown into extraordinary situations. Here, it feels like no one, least of all the viewer, quite knows what world we’re in.
The Trouble With Abandoning Logic
Coben’s hallmark has always been the puzzle. You watch, rewind, re-examine clues, and smugly try to guess the twist before it lands. That satisfaction vanishes when the show itself isn’t playing by its own rules.
By introducing a full-blown supernatural element, Lazarus removes the tension of deduction. When ghosts are literal, there’s no joy in piecing the mystery together, any revelation can simply appear out of thin air.
That doesn’t mean supernatural thrillers can’t work (The Sixth Sense pulled it off decades ago), but Lazarus never feels certain of its own tone. Is it a psychological drama about trauma and grief? A ghost story? A detective procedural? It’s all of them at once, and yet none of them convincingly.
When Coben Clicks, and When He Doesn’t
At his best, Harlan Coben writes thrillers that make you cancel plans. The Five, Safe, and Fool Me Once all hit that sweet spot between trashy and prestige, spinning implausible plots into high-octane, watch-it-now entertainment.
Lazarus tries for something different, more metaphysical and more emotional, but loses the sharp pacing that keeps his other shows propulsive. It’s competently made, often beautifully shot, and Claflin commits fully, but the spark just isn’t there.
For a show about resurrection, it’s oddly lifeless.
Verdict: Not Dead, But Not Completely Alive Either
There’s a version of Lazarus that could have been fascinating, one that leaned fully into either its supernatural weirdness or its detective roots. Instead, it hovers uneasily between the two, a stylish but muddled experiment from a creator whose formula perhaps didn’t need reinventing.
Still, for completists and die-hard Coben fans, it’s worth at least a look. His fingerprints are unmistakable: damaged families, shadowy conspiracies, morally grey heroes, and the sense that everyone knows more than they’re letting on.
But if you’re hoping for another Fool Me Once or The Stranger, Lazarus might leave you feeling more confused than compelled.
Where to Watch
Lazarus is streaming now on Prime Video, with all episodes available from October 25.